Watch this workshop replay to understand the full First-Then Strategy, and learn how a simple first then board can make everyday routines more predictable for your autistic child.
Want to Work with us one-on-one to develop your child’s skills?
What Is the First-Then Strategy?
The First-Then Strategy (also called the first then contingency, the if-then contingency or “grandma’s rule”) pairs something your child finds harder or less interesting with something they enjoy straight afterwards: “First shoes, then park.” It is based on Premack’s principle, which says that the chance to do a preferred activity can motivate a less preferred one.
Key takeaways: first then board
- Show what’s next: a first then board splits a card into First and Then, so your child sees what happens now and next.
- Pair hard with fun: the first then strategy pairs a less preferred task with a preferred activity straight afterwards, such as first shoes, then park.
- Keep it simple: choose clear photos, offer two options for the then, and follow through straight away every time.
- Avoid common problems: break a big first into small steps, use it in calm moments rather than meltdowns, and address sensory pain first.
- Choose real motivators: the then must truly motivate your child right now, and offering it after a tantrum starts turns it into bribery.
Used well, First-Then makes the day more predictable. Many autistic children find it easier to start a task when they can see what comes next, especially when it is shown with pictures on a simple First-Then board.
What Is One Problem With a First-Then Strategy?
One problem with a first-then strategy is that it only works when the “then” is genuinely motivating for your child right now and they trust it will happen. If it isn’t, or if the “first” is too long or too hard, the strategy quickly turns into a power struggle. Other common problems:
- It slides into bribery. If the reward is offered after distress has already started, it no longer previews the day. It becomes a way to end the moment.
- The “first” is too big. “First get dressed” may be several hard steps. Break it down (“First socks, then one minute of TV”) and build up slowly.
- The child doesn’t yet understand “first” and “then”. Start with two things your child loves, so they learn the sequence and learn that you always follow through.
- It is used during a meltdown. A child in a meltdown or shutdown is overwhelmed, not refusing. First-Then is a planning tool for calm moments, not a way to push through distress.
- The task hurts. If the “first” involves sensory pain (a scratchy label, a loud hand dryer, a toothbrush that feels awful), change the environment or the tool first. No reward should be used to make a child tolerate pain.
Used as a predictable, respectful visual support rather than a tool for compliance, First-Then can make transitions and everyday routines much easier for the whole family.
How to Make and Use a First Then Board
A first then board (also called a first then visual or first then chart) is a card or strip split into two boxes: “First” on the left and “Then” on the right. You place one picture in each box so your child can see what is happening now and what comes next.
- Make the board. Use a piece of card, label the two halves “First” and “Then”, and laminate it. Add Velcro dots so pictures can be swapped.
- Choose clear pictures. Photos of your child’s own toothbrush, shoes or favorite toy often work better than drawings.
- Pick a short “first”. One small step, not a whole routine.
- Let your child help choose the “then”. Offer two options and use the one they pick.
- Follow through every time. Point to each box as it happens, and give the “then” straight away.
Once your child is comfortable with two steps, you can grow the board into a longer first then visual schedule or use transition cards for changes between activities.
Workshop Transcript (Edited for Readability)
Concept of Rewards
Hey parents! Ash Bhattacharya here from Autism 360. While I wait in my car to pick up my daughter from her piano lesson, I thought I’d spend a couple of minutes talking about the concept of rewards, because I know there has been a lot of discussion lately about whether rewarding your child for a job well done is a good idea or not.
So here is my take on this. I believe rewards are not necessarily a bad thing, because in its truest definition, a reward is something that needs to be earned, right? Rewards can actually help our kiddos show positive behavior, help them learn new skills and possibly even help you out with the household chores.
Let me explain with an example of how rewards can motivate people, including kids, to show positive behavior. Let’s assume I’m working full time, and at the end of the year, because I have worked really well, my employer is very happy with my performance and offers me a bonus, or maybe a pay rise.
Just because I’ve got this bonus doesn’t make me feel entitled to a bonus next year as well, because I know it is something I really need to work towards. If I want a similar bonus next time, I can’t just stay the same. I need to be a better version of myself, because I want to raise the standard.
I have also raised my management’s expectations to a particular standard. So next time, to earn a similar bonus, I probably need to go beyond that standard.
So you see how it encourages me to show positive behavior: I feel motivated, and I feel fulfilled having earned this recognition. I feel energized to contribute even more, possibly 110%, next time to earn my reward.
Now, compare that with bribery. When we bribe our kids, that is when we show a real sign of weakness. What do I mean by bribery? Essentially, it is something the child didn’t need to work towards.
For example, maybe they are having a tantrum or giving you a hard time, and just to get yourself out of the situation, you offer them the iPad, or a chocolate or a cookie. That is a sign of weakness on our part, because we are giving in to what may be unreasonable demands.
By doing so, we send the wrong message. Kids learn that next time they show a similar behavior, they will be able to get something good out of it.
So instead of helping them reach new levels, it teaches them to show more and more of that behavior, so that you feel more frustrated and hand over a bigger reward the next time. Does that make sense?
So the question is, how do you use rewards effectively, so they are powerful and motivating enough to help your child bring out the best version of themselves? I don’t want to share 20 different strategies, although many strategies exist.
What I want you to focus on for the next 20 minutes is just one strategy, called the if-then contingency. Ella Bailey, one of the behavior coaches in my team, recently ran a workshop with our Autism 360 parents where she explained the strategy beautifully.
It would be really helpful if you could focus for the next 20 minutes to find out exactly how the strategy works. I believe that just by using this one strategy well, you will go a long way in using rewards effectively for your child and helping them achieve more. I hope you enjoy this workshop, and do let me know your thoughts and comments.
Hi everybody. We are on to week two of our mini behavior crash course within our group series. Today we’re going to talk about the First-Then Contingency, which is all about harnessing the behavioral motivation we talked about last time.
If you weren’t here for that, don’t stress, it’s being recorded. You can listen to it whenever you like, and I’m also going to explain everything you need to know today. Here’s a brief outline.
I’m going to introduce myself and what we’re talking about, then give a mini vocab lesson on the terms we use in behavior support. Then we’ll move on to Premack’s principle, which is the research behind the First-Then Contingency.
Then we’ll work through some examples and some troubleshooting ideas for things that commonly come up when we’re trying to use the First-Then Contingency.
We’ll then dive a little deeper into using the First-Then Contingency with early learners. At the end, I’ll walk you through some extra resources so you can learn a bit more about it, and then we’ll have time for discussion and questions.
About Me: Ella
So let’s get started. Hi everybody! I’m Ella. I’m a behavioral specialist here at Autism 360. My background and degree are in psychology. I’ve been working in behavior therapy and behavior support for about seven years, particularly with kiddos on the spectrum, but also with children with a broad variety of developmental delays.
My background is very much in day-to-day, hands-on behavior support in the home, and in how we can help behavior work better for our kiddos, which is always the aim. Today’s webinar builds a little on my last session.
We’ll briefly go over some of the things we talked about then, and then build on that to talk about the behavioral contingency. Last time we talked a little about behavioral drives: the things that drive our kiddos to do what they do.
Shaping Behavior
We talked about internal and external drives, and escape, compulsion and attention-maintained behaviors. These behavioral drives are what cause behaviors to show up in our kiddos, and the way we respond will shape that behavior, either making it more likely or less likely to happen again. Working out which drive sits behind a behavior is exactly what a functional behavior assessment does.
We also learned last time that anything that comes directly after a behavior, whether we intend it as our response or not, will directly affect that behavior and either increase it or decrease it.
Mini Vocabulary
Let’s do a little vocab so we’re all on the same page. Today we’re going to talk a lot about low and high probability behaviors. That’s just a fancy way of saying a behavior your kid would do anyway, and a behavior your kid wouldn’t do without your prompting.
A low probability behavior is one that is very unlikely to happen without the offer of some kind of reward or reinforcement. A high probability behavior is one that would likely happen unprompted, without the offer of any reinforcement.
An example of a low probability behavior might be eating broccoli. An example of a high probability behavior might be watching YouTube on the iPad. The word “reinforcer” is a behavioral term for something (an item or an activity) that happens directly after the target behavior and increases the likelihood of that behavior happening again. If you want to go deeper, our differential reinforcement FAQ explains how reinforcement is used to build helpful skills.
“Punisher” sounds like a harsh word, but in this context it doesn’t mean anything particularly bad. It just means anything that happens after a behavior that decreases the likelihood of that behavior happening again. And motivation, as we spoke about before, is the underlying state that causes the behavior to happen.
Premack’s Principle
Next is Premack’s principle of relative reinforcement, which sounds fancy, but I promise it isn’t. It’s super simple. Essentially, we want to harness the motivation your kid already has to increase helpful behaviors, using Premack’s principle of relative reinforcement, or the First-Then Contingency.
The First-Then Contingency is based on Premack’s principle of relative reinforcement: the opportunity to engage in a more probable behavior will reinforce engaging in a less probable behavior. Sounds fancy!
All it means is that if something good is on offer, we’re more likely to do the thing we don’t want to do. In day-to-day terms, when the thing your kiddo needs to do is followed directly by something they want, it is more likely to happen again in future.
A lot of people call it grandma’s law: first eat your veggies, then you get dessert. It’s super simple, but it’s a really helpful way of shaping behavior. Parents know their kids best. They know what’s going to motivate them and what will drive them to do something.
We want to use that motivation, not to make a child do anything they don’t want to do, but to make everyday routines work better. Premack took this even further, with something parents instinctively know, called response deprivation theory.
It means that the less access your kiddo has to the high probability behavior (for example, the iPad), the more likely they are to do the low probability behavior to get access to it. For example, your kiddo is more likely to tidy their room for a big tub of lollies if they haven’t already been eating them for three hours.
Everybody knows that, but it’s a behavioral law we can use to understand what’s going on. In practical terms, the more you ration something, the more it will motivate your kiddo. So let’s talk about actions.
The first thing to do when using the First-Then Contingency is to establish your exact expectations. You need to know clearly and simply what you want your kid to do. You just need one specific behavior.
At this stage we’re not talking about a long string of behavioral training. We want one building block. We need to know exactly what we’re going to ask for and what we’re going to offer, which brings us to the second step: a reinforcer preference assessment.
For our kiddo to be most motivated to do the less probable behavior, we need the most powerful reinforcer we have. For example, I might hold up Lego in one hand and your kid’s favorite soft toy in the other.
You say, “Oh, which one would you like?” Which one is more motivating to you right now? Kids’ preferences come and go. Sometimes they like mushrooms, sometimes they don’t.
What we’re trying to do is find the most motivating item or activity, whatever we’re using as a reinforcer, before we present the contingency.
When we start presenting the contingency after the behavior has already happened, after refusal or after a tantrum, that’s when it becomes bribery.
We’re trying to stay away from that. We’re trying to plan ahead for the low probability behaviors and catch them before they become a problem. This is the thinking behind antecedent interventions in ABA: changing what happens before a behavior rather than reacting after it. So then we present the First-Then Contingency with the item we’ve already found to be your kiddo’s top preference.
For example, first brushing teeth, then reading a story with Mom or Dad. Depending on where your kid is developmentally, you can present the First-Then either verbally or visually. For early learners, a visual representation is extra great.
For our hyperlexic kiddos, or kids who are a bit older, a verbal “first, then” is going to be totally fine, and they’ll understand it.
What’s really important, once the low probability behavior has been completed, is to make the reinforcer available immediately. You want to connect the first, low probability behavior with the second, reinforcing high probability behavior.
We really want them connected in the mind, because that’s what will increase the likelihood of the target behavior happening over time. We’re going to look through a few examples and talk about how they work as reinforcement.
The thing is, these kinds of contingencies are happening all the time without us even knowing it, for kids and for adults. Once you start to see them around you, it’s like you’ve learned to read: you can’t unsee them.
Working Through Examples
Here are some examples we’ll analyze together to see how they apply. The first one, brushing teeth and Lego, is obviously a kid’s example. Let’s say our kiddo hates brushing their teeth, but they have mastered the motor skills, any sensory issues have been addressed, and they can do it independently.
Before asking them to brush their teeth, we hold up, for example, Lego or a book, and our kiddo decides that at this stage Lego is more motivating. So we say, “All right, great! First brush teeth, then Lego.”
By linking those two together, we increase the likelihood that brushing teeth will happen independently in the future. Something a lot of parents don’t realize (and a lot of people in general) is that behavioral contingencies often happen in reverse.
This isn’t on purpose. It’s often incidental. We find ourselves in a situation where, for example, our kiddo is having a tantrum. Not an autistic meltdown, but something that is purely behavioral.
They’ve asked for the iPad and we’ve said no, or put in some sort of boundary or time limit, and they are having a tantrum. Essentially, the behavioral contingency is in reverse: “First give me the iPad, then I’ll stop crying.”
If we say “Okay, yes” in that situation, we are reinforcing that first behavior. (Calmly holding the boundary instead is covered in our post on extinction in ABA.) And if we remember from our vocab lesson, a reinforcer is anything that increases the likelihood of a behavior happening again in the future.
These kinds of behavioral contingencies are all around us. Another one I hear a lot of parents talk about is falling asleep. We need our kiddo to sleep, obviously, but we may not want to, or have the time to, sit with them and pat them while they fall asleep.
However, we’re motivated by the likelihood of our child getting to sleep quickly, which is the second, reinforcing behavior. So the low probability behavior (one of us sitting with them) is going to increase.
We sit through it with the promise of the reward of them getting to sleep earlier. That’s the same behavioral contingency at work.
Troubleshooting
Now let’s move through some troubleshooting issues we often see when putting the if-then contingency in place with our kiddos. Mostly, we hear, “It’s not working. I’m offering the ‘then’, I’m giving them something, and they’re still not doing what I need them to do.”
What I’d say then is: if you’re offering your kid access to an activity or a tangible item as the high probability behavior, and your kiddo still isn’t doing the target behavior, then your reinforcer is not reinforcing that behavior.
By definition, it isn’t a reinforcer, because it isn’t increasing the behavior. What you need to do is go back a few steps. Find some other items or activities and do another preference assessment to see what they want. Especially try items they haven’t had access to in a while, because, as we talked about, the less access they have to something, the more motivating it is.
Then try again. That is one of the main things parents say to me: “I’m doing the thing and it’s not working.” Try something else. It’s clearly not a motivating enough item for your child, and you need to find something more motivating in a preference assessment.
Another one I hear a lot is, “My child can’t stay on task long enough for me to give them the reinforcer.” A lot of parents have this problem. They’re literally waiting there with the reinforcer, but their child can’t stay on task.
They get distracted, or they become upset halfway through. My suggestion there is that you might be asking for too long a chain of behaviors. We may need to break the contingency down into something much smaller and build it up again.
For example, instead of saying “First get dressed, then TV” as the First-Then Contingency, we say “First put on your socks, then one minute of TV.”
The target task is so short that we know they’re not going to drift off task. And it is not bad to break it down into small chunks.
In fact, if you’re concerned your child may not get all the way through a task, start smaller. You need to set them up for success so they build momentum and trust that the reinforcer will come through. That’s how you make progress. If you would like a behavior coach to help you set this up for your own child, our Guided Support program is parent-led, NDIS-funded support for families in Australia.
Early Learner Implementation
Another issue that comes up with the Premack principle is using it with early learners. Sometimes kiddos on the spectrum don’t yet understand the “first, then” idea of a sequence of events, or they may not yet trust that the person will follow through with the reinforcer they chose in their preference assessment.
In that situation, we need to wind it right back and start with two highly preferred activities in a row. The First-Then Contingency is still in place, but both are high probability behaviors.
The child will do both of them anyway. All we’re doing is setting up the time sequence for them to follow, and building trust: “Yes, I do follow through. The second thing is definitely going to happen. I’m definitely going to give you the iPad once you’ve done this.”
So we start with two highly preferred activities, and once the child has built up trust that you will follow through on what you say, you can change the first activity to something a little less preferred.
For example, for a kiddo who loves trucks and books, we might say “First trucks, then books”, even though they’re at a similar level of preference.
Once that kiddo understands the idea of “first, then”, we change the first activity (the trucks) to something they like a little less, such as a bike.
So “first bike, then book” is not too much of a challenge, but a little more of a challenge than two highly preferred activities. Now we’ll move on to questions and further reading.
Question Time
Let me open my chat so I can see everybody, because this is where the real discussion happens. Let’s see who’s here. If you want to put your comments in the chat, we can talk about them. Let’s see what we’ve got here. Okay!
Ash Bhattacharya is the co-founder and CEO of Autism 360, a global autism brand pioneering parent-mediated intervention. Ash is an autistic adult who grew up in the 1980s with an older autistic brother with high support needs, at a time when there was barely any awareness of autism, let alone acceptance. He saw what his parents faced after his brother’s diagnosis, and how little has changed since for families trying to find support they can afford and access.
That lived experience drives his work. Ash built Autism 360 to put parents in the director’s seat, with the tools, strategies and clinical backing to lead their child’s progress at home. Autism 360 is a registered NDIS provider supporting families across Australia, the USA, Canada and the UK, with outcome-focused programs delivered by speech pathologists, occupational therapists, psychologists and behavior analysts. Ash is a leading advocate for parent empowerment and for making effective autism support affordable and accessible to every family.




